choosing a murder mystery party game

This page takes you through choosing a murder mystery party game, starting with the number of players...

Playing Hollywood Lies, a murder mystery party gamePlaying Hollywood Lies

How to choose?

It can sometimes be a bit difficult to choose the right murder mystery party game for your guests (particularly when there are over 20 murder mystery party games featured on this site).

Here, then is a simple guide through the process.

First you need to answer a simple question:

How many guests?

Why start with the number of guests at your party?

Because it's the most important constraint when choosing a murder mystery game.

You can't play a game for 20-24 if you only have 16 coming to your party.

Most murder mystery party games that I recommend will accommodate different numbers of players. But even so, there is always a minimum number.

Important Tip: Try to fill a party

In general, I would try to fill a party.

As an example, imagine that you have 15 people coming to your party, and you're torn between one murder mystery game for 10-17 people and one for 14-40.

In this situation I would generally choose the smaller game.

The reason for that is that in my experience the games generally work slightly better the closer they are to their maximum player size.

(I must stress that the games work brilliantly with the minimum number of players - so if you like a particular game's theme and only have the minimum number of players, then you should still go for that. But the games often work better with more players.)

If you don't know how many people are likely to turn up you should make an estimate and choose a game that caters for a wide range of people.

How do you know which characters to use?

Curse of the Pharaoh murder mysteryA tender moment in Curse of the Pharaoh

All murder mystery party games come with full instructions for which characters to use and which characters are optional.

So if you only have 10 players and you choose a game that can cope with up to 12, then the instructions will tell you which 10 characters to use.

(Sometimes you may have to give the characters that you do use some extra information that would have otherwise been known only by the characters you aren't using, but it's all clearly explained.)

And as for those remaining characters - they either haven't appeared, or they have been struck ill or otherwise simply aren't around.

As I said above, I recommend that you try and fill your games - but the games are written to be played perfectly well with the minimum of players.

Where to go next?

Click on the link below that suits the size of your party.

theme parties

If you've got a specific theme in mind, you should check my themed parties page (these games are also included in the pages above):

kid's parties

Kids can play murder mysteries too!

If you are mixing kids with adults, then you can just use one of the games above - quite a few of the games already have parts for kids in them.

(However, for some you might want to vet the roles beforehand just in case they aren't suitable for your kids!)

Alternatively, there are also some murder mystery party games that are designed for kids.

good clean fun

While none of the murder mystery party games are explicitly violent or contain swearing, quite a few of them have references to drugs and include a wide range of frankly dubious characters who might be blackmailing each other or having affairs.

(Of course, I can't guarantee that someone won't find something in one of the games offensive - these games include murder after all. You know your guests and must use your own judgement.)

Plus the games inevitably have a murder - sometimes more than one!

Murder mystery games are ideal for most open-minded people with a sense of humor - however some people are more conservative than others.

Luckily, some games are more suitable for those types of groups and don't have references to drugs and have fewer shady characters.

naughty but fun

And as there are "good clean fun" games, there are a number that you wouldn't want to invite Aunt Marge or the local church group to.

These games do contain mature themes and characters - including references to infidelity, alcoholism, narcotics and more.

They aren't suitable for the easily offended!


Have your say about what you just read! Leave me a comment in the box below.

Don't know where to start?

Here's my suggested quick route through the site:

Step 1 - Go to Choosing a Game to choose the game that suits your party best.

Step 2 - Review the Tips for Hosts for helpful advice.

Step 3 - If you want to keep up to date with the latest murder mystery game news, click on my What's New page.

Step 4 - Once you've had your party - tell me how it went! Click here to tell me your murder mystery party story.

Recent Articles

  1. Game for one guesser?

    Mar 31, 20 02:35 PM

    My friend's birthday is coming up, but we are all stranded at home because of the pandemic. In lieu of a party, we thought a murder mystery would be the

    Read More

  2. Murder mystery weddings

    Mar 04, 20 02:18 PM

    I read on a post that The Final Destination murder mystery has a part that’s a proposal? Or can be turned into a marriage proposal. I was just wondering

    Read More

  3. Are your games flexible?

    Feb 22, 20 02:44 AM

    I want a flexible game for up to 20 people, ie where the murderer is only chosen on the night after the guests arrive, so that if someone is poorly etc,

    Read More